CO129-227 - Acting Governor Marsh - 1886 [6] — Page 560

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

Means should be adopted, if possible. The manner in which I should wish to meet an outbreak of violence would be, instantly to seize ringleaders, march them to the office, try them, and award corporal punishment, a step which, in my opinion, would intimidate the rest. But to do this, I must have the summary powers recommended by the Committee, and formerly possessed by the Superintendents of this Gaol. It would lose all the efficacy of prompt example if I had to wait for the Visiting Justice, who might not be able to come for a day or two and might also perhaps not be equal to the occasion. I should add that I do not ask the power of carrying out the sentence of corporal punishment without the ordinary delay of 12 hours after approved by the Governor. I only ask the power at once summarily to try and announce the sentence, subject to the Governor's approval.

With regard to the assistance of temporary extra warders, I think this would be unnecessary and even disadvantageous, as leading the Prisoners to suppose that they were expected to give trouble. The guards are, I consider, sufficient to maintain order, though perhaps a few soldiers to keep the guards on the watch might be desirable for the purpose of preventing escapes. Under these circumstances, and with these views, my recommendations are:

1st That the reduction of punishment diet be at once enforced, say, from Monday next.

2nd That the reductions in fish and Pork diet be postponed until the power of summary corporal punishment (subject to Governor's approval in each case) be restored.

Edit History

2026-05-25 03:57:42 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
Means should be adopted, if possible. The manner in which I should wish to meet an outbreak of violence would be, instantly to seize ringleaders, march them to the office, try them, and award corporal punishment, a step which, in my opinion, would intimidate the rest. But to do this, I must have the summary powers recommended by the Committee, and formerly possessed by the Superintendents of this Gaol. It would lose all the efficacy of prompt example if I had to wait for the Visiting Justice, who might not be able to come for a day or two and might also perhaps not be equal to the occasion. I should add that I do not ask the power of carrying out the sentence of corporal punishment without the ordinary delay of 12 hours after approved by the Governor. I only ask the power at once summarily to try and announce the sentence, subject to the Governor's approval. With regard to the assistance of temporary extra warders, I think this would be unnecessary and even disadvantageous, as leading the Prisoners to suppose that they were expected to give trouble. The guards are, I consider, sufficient to maintain order, though perhaps a few soldiers to keep the guards on the watch might be desirable for the purpose of preventing escapes. Under these circumstances, and with these views, my recommendations are: 1st That the reduction of punishment diet be at once enforced, say, from Monday next. 2nd That the reductions in fish and Pork diet be postponed until the power of summary corporal punishment (subject to Governor's approval in each case) be restored.
Baseline (Original)
A. means should be adopted, if possible. The manner in which I should wish meet an outbreak of violence would be, instantly to seize ringleaders, march them to the office, try them, and award corporal punishment, a step which in. my opinion would intimidate the rest. But to do this Imust have the Summary powers recommended by the Committee, and formerly possessed by the Superintendents of this Gaol. It would love all the efficacy of prompt example if I had jint for the Visiting Justice, who might to come for a day or to seiid not be able to come. who two and might also perhaps not be equal to the occasion. I should add that I donot ask the power of carrying out the sentence of corporal punishment without the ordinary de ordinary delay of 12 hours ould approved by the Governor. I only ask the power at once summarily to to try and announce the sentence subject 558 subject to the Governor's approval. With soldier ao regard to the assistance of temporary extra warders, I think this would be unnecessary. and eveu disadvantageous, as leading the Prisoners to suppose that they were expected to give Zurukeys and guards trouble. The guards are, I consider, sufficient to maintain order, though perhaps a few vor soldiers to keep the guards on the changang might be desirable for the purpose of preventing scapes. Iluver these circumstances, and with these views, my. recommendations are 1th That the reduction of punishment diet be at once enforced, say, from Monday next. 2nd that the reductions in fish and Pork diet be postponed until the power of summary corporal punishment (subject to Governor' = approval in each case) be restored
2026-05-25 03:57:42 · Baseline
View content

A.

means should be adopted, if possible. The manner in which I should wish

meet an outbreak of violence would be, instantly to seize ringleaders, march them to the office, try them, and award corporal punishment, a step which in.

my opinion would intimidate the rest. But to do this

Imust have the Summary powers recommended by the Committee, and formerly possessed by the Superintendents of this Gaol. It would love all the efficacy of prompt example if I had jint

for the Visiting Justice, who might

to come for a day or

to seiid

not be able to come.

who

two and

might also perhaps not be equal

to the occasion. I should add that I

donot ask the power of carrying out the sentence of corporal punishment without the ordinary de

ordinary delay of 12 hours ould approved by the Governor. I only ask the power at once summarily

to

to try and announce the sentence

subject

558

subject to the Governor's approval.

With

soldier

ao

• regard to the assistance of temporary

extra warders, I think this would be unnecessary.

and eveu

disadvantageous, as leading the Prisoners to suppose that they

were expected to give Zurukeys

and guards

trouble. The

guards are, I consider, sufficient to maintain order, though perhaps a few vor

soldiers to keep the guards

on

the changang might be desirable for the purpose of preventing scapes. Iluver these circumstances, and

with these views,

my.

recommendations

are

1th That the reduction of

punishment diet be at once

enforced,

say, from Monday next.

2nd that the reductions in

fish

and Pork diet be postponed until the power of summary corporal punishment (subject to Governor' = approval in each case) be restored

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.